Friday, January 14, 2011

Winning Strategies for Liberal Politics: Learning from South Africa

India FNF Alumni Network (IFAN) in partnership with Friedrich-Naumann-Stiftung für die Freiheit Invites you to a discussion on "Winning Strategies for Liberal Politics: Learning from South Africa" on Thursday, 20 January 2011, New Delhi.


Speaker: Ms. Katja M. Egger, FNF South Africa
Moderator: Barun Mitra, Liberty Institute


Registration: 1530 hrs onwards
Hi-Tea: 1530 hrs - 1600 hrs
Discussion: 1600 hrs – 1800 hrs

Venue: USO House, 6 Special Institutional Area, New Delhi 110 067

RSVP: India FNF Alumni Network, New Delhi
Mobile nos.: 9818499293 (Nupur Hasija, FNF New Delhi)



Speaker Profile

Katja Egger is the Project Officer and head of the Friedrich-Naumann-Stiftung für die Freiheit Office in Cape Town, South Africa since 2008. In this capacity, she has managed the work of the Foundation with its long time partner-The Democratic Alliance (SA’s liberal party). Her areas of expertise are political consultancy and education, democracy, rule of law and human rights. She consults and trains South African and Southern African politicians at national, provincial and municipal level on organizational development, strategy, communication, leadership, team building and conflict management. She develops, designs, facilitates and moderating workshops on these themes on a regular basis within the region and also at the International Academy for Leadership in Germany. A lawyer by profession, she has also taught various law related subjects at the University of Berne in Switzerland.


Nupur Hasija
Executive, Coordination

Friedrich-Naumann-Stiftung für die Freiheit
Regional Office, South Asia
USO House, 6 Special Institutional Area
New Delhi, India

Tel.: +91-11-26862064, 26863846
Fax: +91-11-26862042

Thursday, January 13, 2011

Assembly by-elections in five States announced

The Election Commission of India announced that by-elections to fill up six Assembly seats in five States will be held. In Kharsawan, by-elections will be held on on February 10, the notification being issues on January 17th and counting of votes on February 17th. In Chhattisgarh , Gujarat , Manipur and Madhya Pradesh, the election is scheduled for February 14 and the notification will be issued on January 21, reports The Hindu.

NEW DELHI: The Election Commission on Wednesday announced by-elections to fill up six Assembly seats in five States.

In the Kharsawan (ST) constituency in Jharkhand, the poll will be held on February 10 and the notification will be issued on January 17. The counting of votes will be on February 17.

In Chhattisgarh (Sanjari Balod constituency), Gujarat (Khadia), Manipur (Konthoujam) and Madhya Pradesh (Kukshi-ST and Sonkatch-SC), the election is scheduled for February 14 and the notification will be issued on January 21. The counting of votes will take place on February 17.

Regarding Jharkhand, the EC said the State government conveyed to the Commission that Chief Minister Arjun Munda, who assumed office on September 11, 2010, due to constitutional requirement had to become a member of the Legislative Assembly on or before March 10, 2011.

Wednesday, January 12, 2011

Election Commission may reduce minimum voting age to 16

The Election Commission of India is examining a proposal to reduce the minimum age of voting right to 16 years from the present age of 18. Chief Election Commissioner Y S Quraishi said "We may recommend to the government to reduce the minimum voting age to 16 years, if more youths, particularly new voters, participate in the electoral process," in a meeting organized by Youth United for Voter Awareness, an NGO, reports The Indian Express.

The Election Commission today said it was examining a proposal to reduce the minimum age for voting right to 16 years from the existing 18.

"We may recommend to the government to reduce the minimum voting age to 16 years, if more youths, particularly new voters, participate in the electoral process," Chief Election Commissioner Y S Quraishi told a meeting organised by Youth United for Voter Awareness (YUVA), an NGO.

Though above 35 per cent of voters were youths, their participation was the lowest, he said.

Quraishi said though the minimum voting right age was reduced to 18 from 21 years, participation of new voters was not up to expectation.

As the present day youths were well versed with technologies and comparatively better informed, there was no harm in reducing the minimum voting right age to 16 years, he said.

The EC will launch an awareness drive among students to inform about the rights and significance of participation, he said.

The awareness campaign would include meetings, rallies, seminars and other activities to attract youths to the electoral process, the CEC said after releasing a document prepared by YUVA on youth participation in elections.

Quraishi also said the EC was working on establishing the Indian Institute of Democratic Studies on the lines of IIT and IIM to educate government officials, students and others from within the country and abroad about various aspects of the democratic processes.

Monday, January 10, 2011

Sunlight to electric light

India is a democracy, but without flaws. Disclosure of information could be not just of public servants, but of corporate sector or educational institutions and media. It need not be coercive. It can even be voluntary. Because of Election Commission affidavits, we know 543 MPs in the 15th Lok Sabha have a combined wealth of Rs 3,075 crore, Namma Nageswara Rao leading the field with Rs 174 crore. The battle that there should be disclosure and that disclosure should be in the public domain, is far from over, writes Bibek Debroy in The Indian Express.

Most people will have heard of Brandeis University, not necessarily of US Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis (1856-1941). Justice Brandeis is credited with the quote, “Sunlight is the best disinfectant.” In any democracy, information and disclosure are like light. Most debates about disclosure have concerned public servants. Consequently, because of Election Commission (EC) affidavits, we know 543 MPs in the 15th Lok Sabha have a combined wealth of Rs 3,075 crore, Namma Nageswara Rao (TDP) leading the field with Rs 174 crore.

Disclosure need not only be about public servants. Much of corporate governance is about disclosure of information, and eventual regulation of educational institutions and the media will be along similar lines. Nor does disclosure have to be mandated by law; it can be voluntary. However, rarely does anyone voluntarily part with information, even if there is no culpability.

...

There is a difference between disclosure and information being placed in the public domain. There is greater reluctance to place information in the public domain. Witness the case of ministers or the judiciary.

...

India is becoming richer. It is democratic, with all the warts and blemishes. And despite some recent question marks, it has a free press. Yet the battle that there should be disclosure and that disclosure should be in the public domain, is far from over. Perhaps this is understandable. The Right to Information Act is a little over five years old and the Official Secrets Act is 87 years old.

...

It divides assets into moveable and immoveable. In the moveable category are cash, deposits, bonds, other financial instruments, motor vehicles, jewellery and other assets (values of claims/ interests).

Cash and deposits should be straightforward enough, though even there, we may have a problem.

Babulal Agrawal is a 1988 batch Chhattisgarh cadre IAS officer. When there was an income-tax raid, it was revealed he possessed 220 bank accounts, with several in names of his peons and maid-servants. But in principle, it should be possible to track down this kind of stuff, even without income tax raids. The EC guidelines state: “Value of Bonds/ Shares/ Debentures as per the latest market value in Stock Exchange in respect of listed companies and as per books in the case of non-listed companies should be given.” Apart from wilful non-declaration, understatement of moveable assets occurs because jewellery is declared at historical costs at which they have been acquired. The guidelines merely state that weight and value of jewellery has to be declared.

If weight is known, it should be a simple matter to revalue jewellery at current market prices. If nothing else, they can be indexed to inflation. By the same token, motor vehicles can be reported at depreciated values. This becomes even more of an issue when it comes to immoveable assets, divided into agricultural land, non-agricultural land, buildings (commercial and residential), houses/ apartments and others (interest in property).

If we raise our eyebrows at perceived under-declaration of assets by MPs, that is primarily because these are undervalued. This is not an MP phenomenon alone, since there is consistent undervaluation of property in registration deeds, partly driven by tax evasion motives and partly by high stamp duties. The point is that present EC guidelines make no attempt to link these to market prices, unlike bonds/ shares/ debentures. Once one accepts that this should be done, one can figure out ways of doing it.

...

While avoiding subjectivity, it is possible to objectively determine current market prices for immoveable assets too. As is the case with circle rates, there will continue to be undervaluation. But at least the quantum of undervaluation will decrease.”

...

Monday, December 27, 2010

The Color Of Money

The Union cabinet cleared the proposal for public funding of elections around this time in 2005.Everyone wants India to initiate a thorough reform of its election processes. The Election Commission is the place to begin that process. Urban India often forgets that the panchayat election is the most contested of all elections and has more money spent per voter than in any other. Public funds should remain for public good, writes Manvendra Singh in The Indian Express.

As if on cue, India periodically begins the debate on public funding for elections. A memory recall reminds me that the Union cabinet cleared the proposal for public funding of elections around this time in 2005. And as far as memory serves, the proposal was sent to the law ministry for approval/processing. Now that sounds exactly like the Afzal Guru file, which is precisely the motive behind the periodical references to this route for electoral reforms.It is everybody’s case that India initiates a thorough reform of its election processes. The Election Commission is the place to begin that process.

...

They are also the elections that have the highest polling percentages. In its obsession with the Parliament and legislature, urban India forgets that the panchayat election is the most contested of all elections. Per voter there is more money spent in a panchayat election than any other. And in fact the Parliament election becomes the cheapest in that sense. And that matches the polling figures too, with panchayats leading the race, and Parliament bringing up the rear. There are various reasons why the panchayat election is the most contested of all, ranging from prestige in the village to the fact of influencing more development funds than any other elected post. All of this stays under the radar, for it doesn’t make good daily conversation in urban India. This is the reality that the country will have to face before it can begin an honest debate on electoral funding reforms.


So where do the panchayat funds come from, when many states don’t have party symbols for those elections? Obviously the money is coming from somewhere, and in proportionately bigger quantities than it does for Parliament elections. Election funding reforms, therefore, must cover the entire gambit of the Indian scenario. It would be discriminatory and snobby if the attention to reform were aimed only at the Parliament or legislature levels. After all, the democratic process covers the entire gamut from panchayat to the Parliament levels.

...

The general Indian attitude towards anything that carries a public fund label is that some of it is for the take. It is taken for granted that a portion can be diverted for other ends, and through other means. And with an impossible implementation procedure, it makes little sense to have public funds for elections. There are various proposals doing the rounds, but none that encompasses the sheer diversity and dynamism of Indian elections. Better let public funds remain for public good. The simplest solution, and one that encourages probity and honesty, is for a transparent and private, corporate, business or any other funding that is tracked by sourcing of monies. Let the funding be from any source, by cheques, and through a monitored bank account. There may be an individual bank account for each candidate, party etc. The sourcing for each constituency can be monitored, as also the vested interests that may exist. The vested interests can then be barred from benefiting financially or otherwise. It will then be known that for a particular panchayat election, the local PWD contractors contributed for a particular candidate. That is how it all begins. Let’s get the picture clear first.

Wednesday, December 22, 2010

Hyderabad, 26 Dec 2010: Workshop on land and property rights

You are cordially invited to a "Symposium on Land Rights & Development" Organised by Liberty Institute, New Delhi, in association with Forum for Good Governance, Hyderabad

Venue: Hyderabad Study Circle, Near Indira Park `X’ Roads, Domalguda, Hyd

On December 26, 2010, Sunday, from 10.30 AM to 4.30 PM

Inaugural Session
Launch of International Property Rights Index 2010 by Dr Y Shivaji, Ex MP

Chief Guest: Justice A Lakshmana Rao, Ex Chief Justice, Allahabad High Court

Keynote address by Dr Barun Mitra, Director, Liberty Institute
President : Sri K Ashok Reddy, Senior Advocate, High Court

Resource Persons:
- Dr B Yerram Raju,
- Prof P Narayana Reddy, CBIT,
- N Saida Rao,
- Ambrish Mehta, ARCH, Gujarat,
- P Sivarama Krishna, Shakti
- P Trinadha Rao, Laya

The discussions will cover urban and rural land related issues. There
will also be a demonstration of a system of mapping land, which may
enable the tribal population document and authenticate their private
agricultural land and village common land, under the Forest Rights
Act.

RSVP : Ch. Narendra, Coordinator, Mobile : 98495 69050,
email : expressnarendra@gmail.com

Sunday, December 19, 2010

Push development to kick corruption

The Radia tapes have exposed the business-politics-media nexus. There are scandals in loans for real estate companies in which PSU banks are implicated, housing allocation, and IPL. One reason for corruption is that there are economic goods—contracts, land deals, permits—available at an administered price that understates their true value. The agent in charge of allocating such goods is in a pivotal position. Corruption is embedded in the democratic political process and the prevailing ideology shared by all parties (conveniently and profitably) that the state must play a large role in economic life, writes Meghnad Desai in The Financial Express.

We have all known about corruption in Indian political and business life. Many of us have had to give bribes to municipal officers, electricity or water suppliers, for telephone connections in the old days or for getting a gas cylinder. Few of us get the chance to take bribes. This is the side of the bargain we only hear about.

...

The Radia tapes have exposed the business-politics-media nexus, which oozes corruption. Along with these, there has been a minor scandal of underhand loans for real estate companies in which PSU banks are implicated. The Maharashtra chief minister resigned for a housing allocation scandal and the Karnataka chief minister refused to resign despite a land scandal. Meanwhile, the IPL continues to speed along its own dubious trajectory. Business tycoons, normally reticent, have begun to speak up about the corruption they encounter. And, all this in a space of four weeks.

...

Why is there so much corruption? One way to see it is that there are economic goods—contracts, land deals, permits—available at an administered price that understates their true value. The agent in charge of allocating such goods is in a pivotal position. He can grant it to you or deny you; he can delay you if you have a right to it and in the ultimate analysis, he can frustrate you be granting something, but in such a way that you can't use it. Jean Jacques Laffont, a brilliant French economic theorist, who died far too young, advanced the hypothesis that corruption is a principal agent problem.

...

Corruption as rent seeking is a familiar idea. The opportunity to exploit the gap between the list price and the market price of controlled goods is obvious. But the need to keep goods under control for allocative purposes also needs to be endogenised. In India, the fashionable argument is that markets cannot be trusted to allocate goods fairly because of market failure. Hence the state has to allocate these goods. But the state is not a person. Its agent is the government, which is represented by politicians in office and their party apparatus. Where governments are honest, there is no need to worry about the gap between the actual and the market price of goods, like the NHS in the UK. I don’t need to bribe my MP to get admitted to a NHS ward for an expensive operation. I don’t need to bribe my local councillor to get planning permission to extend my patio.

So why are governments corrupt in India? They were not always so. In the 1950s, it was known that while there was corruption at lower levels of administration, the top echelons were uncorrupt. The black market, which had begun in the war years, had lasted for a while in the post-war years. Regulations such as prohibition encouraged more such black market, as did custom regulations and tariffs. Black money provided much of the finance for the film industry because the law forbade banks from loaning money to film producers (an anomaly corrected by the NDA government when Sushma Swaraj was the I&B minister). Thus black money did not lie idle; it recycled itself profitably in alcohol, films and often real estate. House purchase remains a black-plus-white payment activity still.

...

Political parties are closed private firms in which outsiders cannot easily enter. They also restrict competition since it costs a lot to start a new party. Since independence, many national parties have folded—PSP, Swatantra, and apart from Jan Sangh renaming itself as BJP, there has been a stable number of parties. Congress, BJP and the Left (itself a divided house) are the only three stable actors at the national level. The Left has never been in power at the Centre (except the brief period of 1996-1998 in a coalition), and, even so, it is probably not very corrupt. The two national parties collude in making a show of fighting corruption, but never harm each other. It also does not benefit them to have an effective and independent anti-corruption agency. There are, indeed, no agencies in India—the top judiciary apart—that are independent of political parties in power, neither civil service nor the police. Even the Army has begun to enjoy the fruits of corruption.

...

I am sceptical of the notion that corruption in India has a cure. It is too embedded in the democratic political process and the prevailing ideology shared by all parties (conveniently and profitably) that the state must play a large role in economic life. Jean Jacques Laffont in his article showed that corruption has U-curve if plotted against per capita income; development is thus a long-term cure for corruption, but his curve turns a corner very late in the development process. The only exception to this U-curve is the group of Scandinavian countries which are not corrupt at all. But that has to do with their religion, the Lutheran Church, and the discipline of their civic life. Religion does not seem to offer any lesson for non-corruption in India; just read the Mahabharat and you see why. So, the only cure is to wait for development .

Wednesday, December 8, 2010

Prospect of liberal politics in India today

The verdict, in the recent assembly election in the state of Bihar, has attracted a lot of interest across India. The ruling coalition of JD(U) and BJP won a record 206 seats in a house of 243. Did this huge margin of victory, signify a major shift in Indian politics? What does this election really tell us about the future political direction in India? In this the second half, the aim is to identify the various strands that dominated Indian politics over the past six decades - language, region, religion, caste, poverty. Is there a diminising political dividend from identity politics, could political ideology find a legitimate space in India, asks Barun Mitra
Read more...

Wednesday, December 1, 2010

'I don’t give a damn' attitude

Stalling of Parliament is a manifestation of growing intolerance in the country. The UPA has behaved in a disgraceful way and the opposition has a point. However, they don't allows the Government to function properly. The ruling Congress, at the same time blames the Opposition for not letting Parliament function. It gives out the impression that cheap stunts matter than performance, writes Ravi Shanker Kapoor .

The Opposition, including the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) and the Left parties, continue to stall Parliament to press their demand that a probe by a Joint Parliamentary Committee (JPC) be instituted to look into the controversial allocation of 2G spectrum. While the anger of the Opposition is justified over the loot of public money, not allowing Parliament to function is tantamount to undermining the very concepts of democracy, individual liberty, and tolerance.

There is no denying the fact that the United Progressive Alliance (UPA) Government has behaved in a disgraceful manner, in not only letting A. Raja continue as telecom minister in the face of growing evidence about his less than proper conduct but also in thwarting his prosecution.

The Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) said, “The entire process of allocation of 2G spectrum raises serious concern about the systems of governance in the Department of Telecommunications which need to be thoroughly reviewed and revamped. The fact that there has been loss to the national exchequer in the allocation of 2G spectrum cannot be denied.”

The Opposition clearly has a point. It has every right to take the Government to task for its sins of omission and commission; for this purpose, it can use the country’s biggest forum, Parliament. But, ironically, BJP and other Opposition leaders do not allow it to function. BJP spokesperson Prakash Javadekar said, “Congress is running away from the JPC and we have decided to stick to our demand. It has been three weeks now that Parliament is not functioning.” Earlier, he had said, “Congress is fully responsible for the impasse in Parliament.”

The ruling Congress, on its part, blames the Opposition for not letting Parliament function.

The most important feature of this blame-game is that all parties are convinced stalling Parliament is not wrong if they deem an issue to be big enough to doing that. In the wake of the Tehelka row when the BJP was in office, the Congress also did not allow Parliament to function; and now, the BJP and other parties think that the 2G scam, the Adarsh housing scandal, and the irregularities in Commonwealth Games warrant their disruptions in both Houses.

But the point is that there will always be issues which one party or the other would find of overwhelming consequence; there would always be something or other that, the Opposition would claim, proves the moral turpitude of those sitting on the Treasury benches. In fact, anything can be construed or misconstrued as great betrayal by the government of the day. Would that always justify the stalling of Parliament?

At the heart of the controversy is our politicians’ belief that good oration and cogent arguments do not matter in our democracy, while cheap stunts like rushing to the well and loud sloganeering do.

I do not argue because I am convinced that my stand is correct and righteous—and that of my opponents is incorrect and willful. It also means that I need not listen to them.

I am convinced that I know all the facts—and my opponents are hopelessly in error. I am convinced that I know everything that is worth knowing—and my opponents are groping in the dark. And since my position is impeccable and infallible, I have a right (even duty) to enlighten the world about my views—which are actually statements of facts, if not gospel truths. It is in my exercise of this right that I don’t allow others to speak. There cannot be any dialogue among the self-righteous.

Further, politicians seem to believe that the people of India do not care about good arguments and articulate speeches; so, in order to impress the electorate, they indulge in theatrics.

Their cantankerousness reminds me of German Chancellor Otto von Bismarck’s famous 1862 speech: “Not through speeches and majority decisions will the great questions of the day be decided… but by iron and blood.”

Thankfully, our political masters are not yet talking about a policy of “iron and blood.” But are they far from it? In the absence of speeches, debates, and discussions, don’t we stand to become an unthinking society?

Intolerance is a natural product in this milieu, and we find it grow in every walk of life. Unsurprisingly, it is often promoted by politicians and their front organizations. Somebody feels that the works of Salman Rushdie and Taslima Nasreen may offend the Muslims, so they are banned or curtailed. Somebody else feels that the paintings of M.F. Hussain blaspheme the Hindu pantheon, so the artist is in the line of fire. A nanny-like minister tries to ban smoking in cinema and on television. The scion of the Thackeray family seeks a high-visibility launch, and a university is forced to withdraw a book from the syllabus. Many more instances can be quoted showing how politicians are bulldozing others in not only the political arena but also in literature, arts, cinema, culture, etc.

The politician of India doesn’t care two hoots for others; his attitude reminds me of Rhett Butler’s famous line in Gone With The Wind, “I don’t give a damn.” Paralyzing Parliament is just the most conspicuous manifestation of the political class’ mindset.

Monday, November 29, 2010

Corruption costs business

Parliament has not been functioning for many days, which leads to severe costs and loss of reputation. The fight against corruption is not rhetorical matter.For decades, India has winked at corruption. The political order has fostered it and financed itself out of corruption. We are caught in a vicious circle where the private sector has to bribe ministers and civil servants if they are to carry on business. Unless all co-operate in exposing the corruption, a few will suffer and the rest will free-ride, writes Meghnad Desai in The Financial Express.

Parliament has not been functioning for many days. Leave alone the daily cost of its operation, but does anyone know or care about its effect on India’s reputation? The UPA or at least the Congress trumpets its virtue in forcing the resignation of Ashok Chavan and Kalmadi and then also belatedly Raja, but is that enough?

...

But leave that aside. The CWG scam was discovered only because the British tax authorities found something dodgy in the tax claims of the company favoured by Kalmadi. This was noticed sharply in the UK. What India does with the CWG scam will affect its chances for winning future sports events contracts. So far, no one has been charged and Kalmadi’s resignation from some footling Congress post is neither here nor there.

And then we have the Raja scandal. Again, the embarrassment at non-action or, at best, delayed action is being taken out on the companies that won the contracts. Trai is threatening to cancel the dubious contracts. Surely, again, that is not only overkill but killing the wrong party. The spectrum allocations were an international event.

...

The issue is simple. As Obama said, India is no longer emerging. It has emerged. With such status, go get some responsibilities. The fight against corruption is not rhetorical matter. It is not about quoting Gandhiji or claiming virtue against the BJP. For decades, India has winked at corruption. The political order has fostered it and financed itself out of corruption. This is well known. The shock at Ratan Tata’s statement that someone had asked him to bribe the minister to get a licence was not that such things go on. But that even as big an industrialist as Ratan Tata is subject to such squalid behaviour. We note that Tata has not got a licence for his airline business.

...

The question is who will bell the cat? Politicians will not do it. Many in the NGO community try their best to disseminate the information. But as Tehelka’s example showed, the political system can fight viciously and destroy you. The private sector has to take the initiative. Thus far, the Indian private sector organisations have been too shy or too afraid to raise the issue. Business pays the price either in cash or in missed contracts, as Ratan Tata’s example shows. If the apex bodies such as Ficci and CII were to open up a debate on this issue and if many more businessmen were to come forward as Ratan Tata did and relate their experience, we may get some action. It is not easy to do, of course. We are caught in a vicious circle (or a degenerate equilibrium, if you like a fancy expression) where the private sector has to bribe ministers and civil servants if they are to carry on business. Unless all co-operate in exposing the corruption, a few will suffer and the rest will free-ride.

The rest of the world is watching. Remember that Raju’s scam in Satyam was spotted on the NYSE. India does not have the luxury of time. It is time for the market to work. The state has failed demonstrably.