Stalling of Parliament is a manifestation of growing intolerance in the country. The UPA has behaved in a disgraceful way and the opposition has a point. However, they don't allows the Government to function properly. The ruling Congress, at the same time blames the Opposition for not letting Parliament function. It gives out the impression that cheap stunts matter than performance, writes Ravi Shanker Kapoor .
The Opposition, including the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) and the Left parties, continue to stall Parliament to press their demand that a probe by a Joint Parliamentary Committee (JPC) be instituted to look into the controversial allocation of 2G spectrum. While the anger of the Opposition is justified over the loot of public money, not allowing Parliament to function is tantamount to undermining the very concepts of democracy, individual liberty, and tolerance.
There is no denying the fact that the United Progressive Alliance (UPA) Government has behaved in a disgraceful manner, in not only letting A. Raja continue as telecom minister in the face of growing evidence about his less than proper conduct but also in thwarting his prosecution.
The Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) said, “The entire process of allocation of 2G spectrum raises serious concern about the systems of governance in the Department of Telecommunications which need to be thoroughly reviewed and revamped. The fact that there has been loss to the national exchequer in the allocation of 2G spectrum cannot be denied.”
The Opposition clearly has a point. It has every right to take the Government to task for its sins of omission and commission; for this purpose, it can use the country’s biggest forum, Parliament. But, ironically, BJP and other Opposition leaders do not allow it to function. BJP spokesperson Prakash Javadekar said, “Congress is running away from the JPC and we have decided to stick to our demand. It has been three weeks now that Parliament is not functioning.” Earlier, he had said, “Congress is fully responsible for the impasse in Parliament.”
The ruling Congress, on its part, blames the Opposition for not letting Parliament function.
The most important feature of this blame-game is that all parties are convinced stalling Parliament is not wrong if they deem an issue to be big enough to doing that. In the wake of the Tehelka row when the BJP was in office, the Congress also did not allow Parliament to function; and now, the BJP and other parties think that the 2G scam, the Adarsh housing scandal, and the irregularities in Commonwealth Games warrant their disruptions in both Houses.
But the point is that there will always be issues which one party or the other would find of overwhelming consequence; there would always be something or other that, the Opposition would claim, proves the moral turpitude of those sitting on the Treasury benches. In fact, anything can be construed or misconstrued as great betrayal by the government of the day. Would that always justify the stalling of Parliament?
At the heart of the controversy is our politicians’ belief that good oration and cogent arguments do not matter in our democracy, while cheap stunts like rushing to the well and loud sloganeering do.
I do not argue because I am convinced that my stand is correct and righteous—and that of my opponents is incorrect and willful. It also means that I need not listen to them.
I am convinced that I know all the facts—and my opponents are hopelessly in error. I am convinced that I know everything that is worth knowing—and my opponents are groping in the dark. And since my position is impeccable and infallible, I have a right (even duty) to enlighten the world about my views—which are actually statements of facts, if not gospel truths. It is in my exercise of this right that I don’t allow others to speak. There cannot be any dialogue among the self-righteous.
Further, politicians seem to believe that the people of India do not care about good arguments and articulate speeches; so, in order to impress the electorate, they indulge in theatrics.
Their cantankerousness reminds me of German Chancellor Otto von Bismarck’s famous 1862 speech: “Not through speeches and majority decisions will the great questions of the day be decided… but by iron and blood.”
Thankfully, our political masters are not yet talking about a policy of “iron and blood.” But are they far from it? In the absence of speeches, debates, and discussions, don’t we stand to become an unthinking society?
Intolerance is a natural product in this milieu, and we find it grow in every walk of life. Unsurprisingly, it is often promoted by politicians and their front organizations. Somebody feels that the works of Salman Rushdie and Taslima Nasreen may offend the Muslims, so they are banned or curtailed. Somebody else feels that the paintings of M.F. Hussain blaspheme the Hindu pantheon, so the artist is in the line of fire. A nanny-like minister tries to ban smoking in cinema and on television. The scion of the Thackeray family seeks a high-visibility launch, and a university is forced to withdraw a book from the syllabus. Many more instances can be quoted showing how politicians are bulldozing others in not only the political arena but also in literature, arts, cinema, culture, etc.
The politician of India doesn’t care two hoots for others; his attitude reminds me of Rhett Butler’s famous line in Gone With The Wind, “I don’t give a damn.” Paralyzing Parliament is just the most conspicuous manifestation of the political class’ mindset.
Showing posts with label UPA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label UPA. Show all posts
Wednesday, December 1, 2010
Saturday, July 24, 2010
Keeping up the acts
The Monsoon session of the parliament will be held from July26th to August 27th. The Government failed to meet its legislative targets in the last sessions. The UPA Government intended to introduce several bills, including the ones on Judicial accountability, four bills on university education, women's reservation and biotechnology regulator.UPA failed to fully utilize these sessions, writes MR Madhavan in The Indian Express.
Excerpts:
"The monsoon session of Parliament will be held from July 26 to August 27. The UPA government has not been able to meet its legislative targets in the last couple of sessions. The government had planned to pass 27 bills and introduce 64 bills in the budget session; it managed only to pass six and to introduce 28 bills."
"A few months after the UPA government was formed, the law minister stated his intention to introduce the Judicial Accountability and Standards Bill. During the last year, issues related to the appointment and conduct of judges have cropped up. "
"If this committee submits the report soon and finds cause for removal of the judge, we may witness the rare case of the removal motion being debated in Parliament. "
"The education minister had introduced four bills related to university education, which addressed the entry of foreign universities, prohibition of capitation fees, establishment of education tribunals and setting up a system of agencies that would provide quality ratings to all courses and institutions. These bills are being examined by the standing committee. Other possible bills include those recognising new IITs, IISERs, and recasting the Distance Education Council. The ministry has also planned a new law that combines into a new regulator the regulatory powers of bodies such as UGC, AICTE, and the Bar Council."
"The trajectory of the Women’s Reservation Bill is difficult to guess. The nuclear liability bill is being examined by the standing committee, which is scheduled to submit its report on the second day of the session. If the committee submits the report in time — reports indicate otherwise — the bill may be taken up for discussion. It would be interesting to see the committee’s recommendations on the contentious issues."
" the last session, the government had planned to introduce the Biotechnology Regulator Bill. Given the fracas over permitting Bt brinjal, it is important to institutionalise mechanisms for permitting and regulating biotechnology including genetically modified organisms."
"Three ordinances have been issued since the last session, and these need to be ratified. The first ordinance replaces the Medical Council of India with a board of directors for one year. This step followed the arrest of the MCI president on corruption charges. The second ordinance followed the row between SEBI and IRDA over the regulation of unit linked insurance products. A new mechanism has been set up to resolve inter-regulator issues. The third ordinance declares that any enemy property will remain with the custodian even if the status of the original owner changes or the legal heir is an Indian citizen."
Every Parliament session is an opportunity for the government to further its legislative agenda. The UPA has not fully utilised earlier sessions. We hope this session is used fruitfully by both treasury and opposition members to fulfil their parliamentary responsibilities.
Excerpts:
"The monsoon session of Parliament will be held from July 26 to August 27. The UPA government has not been able to meet its legislative targets in the last couple of sessions. The government had planned to pass 27 bills and introduce 64 bills in the budget session; it managed only to pass six and to introduce 28 bills."
"A few months after the UPA government was formed, the law minister stated his intention to introduce the Judicial Accountability and Standards Bill. During the last year, issues related to the appointment and conduct of judges have cropped up. "
"If this committee submits the report soon and finds cause for removal of the judge, we may witness the rare case of the removal motion being debated in Parliament. "
"The education minister had introduced four bills related to university education, which addressed the entry of foreign universities, prohibition of capitation fees, establishment of education tribunals and setting up a system of agencies that would provide quality ratings to all courses and institutions. These bills are being examined by the standing committee. Other possible bills include those recognising new IITs, IISERs, and recasting the Distance Education Council. The ministry has also planned a new law that combines into a new regulator the regulatory powers of bodies such as UGC, AICTE, and the Bar Council."
"The trajectory of the Women’s Reservation Bill is difficult to guess. The nuclear liability bill is being examined by the standing committee, which is scheduled to submit its report on the second day of the session. If the committee submits the report in time — reports indicate otherwise — the bill may be taken up for discussion. It would be interesting to see the committee’s recommendations on the contentious issues."
" the last session, the government had planned to introduce the Biotechnology Regulator Bill. Given the fracas over permitting Bt brinjal, it is important to institutionalise mechanisms for permitting and regulating biotechnology including genetically modified organisms."
"Three ordinances have been issued since the last session, and these need to be ratified. The first ordinance replaces the Medical Council of India with a board of directors for one year. This step followed the arrest of the MCI president on corruption charges. The second ordinance followed the row between SEBI and IRDA over the regulation of unit linked insurance products. A new mechanism has been set up to resolve inter-regulator issues. The third ordinance declares that any enemy property will remain with the custodian even if the status of the original owner changes or the legal heir is an Indian citizen."
Every Parliament session is an opportunity for the government to further its legislative agenda. The UPA has not fully utilised earlier sessions. We hope this session is used fruitfully by both treasury and opposition members to fulfil their parliamentary responsibilities.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)